Welcome to Make It Frosted

Custom 3 shaped cookie cake in pink and white
Custom H shaped cookie cake in teal, purple and white
Valentine themed cookie cake in red, pink and white

Follow us on Instagram: @makeitfrosted

Ready to Order?

Contact us to place your custom cookie cake order!

Contact Us

Our Menu

Delicious custom cookie cakes for every occasion

Round Cookie Cakes

Medium Round Cookie Cake (8")
Single layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$30
Medium Round Double Layer (8")
Two-layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$55
Large Round Cookie Cake (10")
Single layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$60
Large Round Double Layer (10")
Two-layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$100

Sheet Cookie Cakes

Medium Sheet Cookie Cake (10"x7.5")
Single layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$40
Medium Sheet Double Layer (10"x7.5")
Two-layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$75
Large Sheet Cookie Cake (15"x10")
Single layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$65
Large Sheet Double Layer (15"x10")
Two-layer sugar cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
$120

Flavor Options

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Rich chocolate chip cookie cake with vanilla buttercream icing. Includes white icing plus 2 custom colors.
+$4 (added to base price)

Customization Options

Additional Icing Colors
Each additional color beyond the included 2 custom colors. First 2 colors are free, 3rd and 4th are $5 each.
+$5 per additional color

Premium Toppings

Sprinkles
Colorful sprinkles to decorate your cookie cake.
+$1
Chocolate Molds
Custom chocolate decorations molded to your specifications.
+$6
Florals
Edible flower decorations for an elegant touch.
+$10
Candy Toppings
Various candy decorations and toppings.
+$10
Happy Birthday Plaque
Custom birthday message plaque.
+$10
Edible Glitter
Sparkling edible glitter for extra shine.
+$10
Toy Toppers
Fun toy decorations for special occasions.
+$10

Allergen Information

Items DO NOT Contain: Gluten
Items Contain: Milk, Eggs, and Soy
Additional toppings may contain peanuts & tree nuts

Please inform us of any allergies when placing your order. We take allergen safety seriously and will work with you to accommodate your needs where possible.